There are a couple of points to be made by an Old Guy on the top three of Martin McCrory’s TNG Top Ten.
BoBW Full credit needs to be given to the TNG writers for exhuming the end-of-season cliff-hanger! This started with the “Who Shot JR” summertime cliffhanger of 1979/80 for the TV show Dallas. Nothing will ever touch THAT, but the hupla around this TNG cliffhanger was fanned, for the first time, by the Internet! Of course, http://www.starttrek.com, or any other web page, did not exist at that time (1990). So Usenet Newsgroups carried the buzz. And what a buzz it was! The rec.arts.startrek newsgroup was a full-time job to read! I spent way too many hours that summer reading it! (Please let me know if you can find the archives of this newsgroup from 1990. The Google version only goes back to 1992.) The anticipation of the conclusion was fantastic!
Of course, now we know that the writers actually didn’t know how to end this episode when they wrote it! But some of the suggestions of the possible resolution on Usenet were awesome. Many of these suggestions showed up later in the Star Trek universe. The one I remember best was that they should beam in hundreds of photon torpedoes and simultaneously detonate them, destroying the cube. This was done in an alternate timeline episode of Voyager.
Next time you watch BoBW part One, turn off the TV and wait for 3 months before you watch it again.
Yesterday’s Enterprise. I agree completely with Marty’s assessment, particularly the part that there are no holes in this time travel episode. Superlative!
The unique aspect of this episode is that they placed the time-travel action in the present! In every other time traveler I know of, the hero travels backward or forward in time to get into some connundrum, which s/he barely escapes, with the timeline in tact. Think, Back to the Future and the classic TOS episode The City on the Edge of Forever. Doctor Who has been time travelling on the BBC since the early 1960’s, but he always traveled to some other time. This is the first time-travel plot line where we, in the “present”, have hosted time travelers. Ingenious! And the perfectly natural way in which Tasha Yar (Denise Crosby) returns is brilliant!